Bette Midler

Winifred Sanderson

Sarah Jessica Parker

Sarah Sanderson

Kathy Najimy

Mary Sanderson

Whitney Peak

Becca

Belissa Escobedo

Izzy

Lilia Buckingham

Cassie

Froy Gutierrez

Mike

Sam Richardson

Gilbert

Doug Jones

Billy Butcherson

Tony Hale

Mayor / Reverend Traske

Hannah Waddingham

The Witch Mother

Taylor Henderson

Young Winifred

Nina Kitchen

Young Mary

Juju Journey Brener

Young Sarah

Thomas Fitzgerald

John Pritchett

Brett Cramp

Mr. Pritchett

Kim Niemi

Townsperson

Alison Weller

Townsperson

Holly Cinnamon

Townsperson

Patrick French

Townsperson

Charlotte Peed

Mrs. Smith

Ed Peed

Mr. Smith

Austin J. Ryan

Young Billy Butcherson

Michael Tow

Mr. Wilke

Brina

School Secretary

Brian Wiles

Rob

Owen Earls

Liam

Skyla Sousa

Teen Winifred

Aiden Torres

Teen Mary

Emma Kaufman

Teen Sarah

Chhoyang Cheshatsang

Thom

Jaylin Pryor

Teen Gilbert

Marissa Carpio

Food Stall Woman

Naheem Garcia

Fred

Dan Finnerty

Lucas

Ginger Minj

Drag Queen Winifred

Kornbread Jeté

Drag Queen Mary

Kahmora Hall

Drag Queen Sarah

Ryan Rosenthal

Glenn

Juvan Elisma

Alex

Jen D'Angelo

Liam's Mom

Mark Fichera

Scary Scarecrow

Jordan von Netzer

Roman Soldier

Mark Hawker

Puppeteer

Shane Dzicek

Puppeteer

CJ Walsh

Puppeteer

David Torres Jr.

Teacher (uncredited)